NCIS: Sydney season 2 brings a fresh take to the franchise with its Australian setting, following U.S. NCIS agents and Australian Federal Police tackling transnational crimes.
In episode 2, Fire in the Hole, Evie and DeShawn face danger while undercover on a historic ship. When DeShawn’s cover is blown, he is shot and falls overboard.
With no backup and surrounded by potential threats, Evie makes a bold choice—she confesses her real identity to the hostage-taker. This moment proves crucial in de-escalating the crisis and ultimately contributes to resolving the situation, highlighting Evie’s ability to think on her feet under extreme pressure.
NCIS: Sydney season 2 : Investigation leads to an unexpected suspect
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/90c40/90c40d7ac5df3b90bf74bc2572978a6360489d58" alt="Still from the series (Image via YouTube/Global TV)"
The case begins when a young girl discovers the body of a U.S. Navy reservist, Lieutenant Brad Shields, floating in the harbor. Though no longer on active duty, his military ties prompt NCIS to take charge of the investigation. Adding to the mystery, Shields was found wearing a pirate costume, an unusual detail that raises immediate questions.
With Mackey and J.D. on the USS Perez, DeShawn and Evie take charge. Their investigation reveals Shields worked on a themed wedding cruise. A call to the ship uncovers a shocking twist—someone aboard is impersonating Shields, who is confirmed dead, making the imposter the prime suspect.
Determined to gather intelligence, DeShawn and Evie infiltrate the ship undercover. DeShawn poses as a photographer, while Evie pretends to be the celebrant officiating a wedding. They embark on their mission without weapons or external support, unaware of how quickly the situation will spiral out of control.
A high-stakes undercover operation turns deadly
As the wedding unfolds, the investigation takes a dire turn. DeShawn’s cover is compromised, resulting in him being shot and thrown overboard.
With her partner missing and an armed threat in control, Evie is left with limited options. Realizing that any wrong move could endanger the hostages further, she makes a risky decision—she reveals her identity as an APD officer in an attempt to regain control of the situation.
Her confession shifts the power dynamic, forcing the hostage-taker to reassess his position. By maintaining her composure and using negotiation tactics, Evie manages to de-escalate the crisis.
Her actions not only prevent further casualties but also lead to the successful apprehension of the perpetrator, proving her ability to adapt under Unraveling the mystery & its broader consequences
Mackey and J.D. handle a critical external threat
While Evie and DeShawn face the hostage crisis, Mackey and J.D. work to prevent a separate, high-risk threat in the harbor—one that could strain U.S.-Australia diplomatic relations. Their mission runs parallel to the murder investigation, adding another layer of urgency to the episode.
Mackey and J.D.’s evolving partnership remains a key element of the season. Following Mackey’s emotional vulnerability in the premiere, this episode further develops their trust and teamwork. Their ability to manage high-pressure situations reinforces the importance of collaboration within the NCIS: Sydney team.
As the NCIS: Sydney season 2 progresses, viewers can expect further character development and gripping investigations.
Catch the latest episode of NCIS: Sydney season 2 streaming on Paramount+.