In the New York City's bustling subway on the morning of April 12, 2022, things took a horrific turn as Frank James, then 62, committed a shocking act of violence that pierced the routine noise of clattering tracks and morning chatter.
Disguised as a construction worker, James unleashed a terrifying barrage of gunfire on a Manhattan-bound train, wounding 10 unsuspecting commuters. The brutal attack not only sowed panic across one of the world’s busiest transit systems but also sparked an intense manhunt that gripped the city.
“In an act of cold-blooded terrorism, this defendant shot 32 rounds at defenseless victims trapped in a subway car during their rush hour commute,” said Director Steven Dettelbach of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF).
The incident ended as dramatically as it began, with James calling a police tip line to turn himself in after more than a day on the run. This concluded the frantic search but opened a chapter of painful recovery for his victims and a series of legal battles that would ultimately lead to Frank getting a life sentence on multiple counts of terrorism.
As Frank James currently serves his sentence, the Paramount+ series PD True revisits the harrowing events through its two-part episode Hunt for the NY Subway Shooter.
How Frank James got caught following NY Subway shooting
The subway car on that fateful day was packed with riders when Frank James, in his disguise, waited for it to leave the station. He then set off multiple smoke bombs as it traveled between stops, creating confusion and reducing visibility, which added to the ensuing panic. Armed with a Glock 17 pistol, he began firing at the victims, aged 16 to 60, injuring 10 of them with the bullets. Dozens more suffered from smoke inhalation and physical and mental injuries.
Frank James' escape was as calculated as his attack. He left behind a key to a rented moving van in the blood-stained subway car, which was a piece of evidence that would later be crucial in identifying him. Despite the chaos, no lives were lost, which the authorities attributed to fortunate circumstances, more so than to any restraint on the shooter's part.
The investigation revealed that James had been planning the attack for years. He had posted multiple videos online under the alias "Prophet of Doom" where he expressed his grievances about societal issues, particularly around race and mental health, which painted a picture of a man deeply troubled by personal demons and societal failure.
In court, the impact of the attack was palpable. Victims shared their ongoing struggles with physical injuries and psychological traumas, such as PTSD and anxiety, which disrupted their everyday lives.
Frank James' defense spoke about his mental health challenges, including diagnoses of paranoid schizophrenia and alcoholism, further suggesting that these factors influenced his actions. They argued for a reduced sentence, citing his lack of intent to kill. However, the prosecution countered this by pointing to the calculated nature of the attack, as well as the victims stating that the gun only stopped firing because it jammed.
Ultimately Frank James was sentenced to 10 concurrent life sentences in prison, plus 10 consecutive years for shooting 10 people. He now resides in a high-security prison. Along with that, the judge condemned his actions as "pure evil", dismissing any excuses linked to mental health failings as insufficient for the gravity of the crime.
“Nothing can undo the damage that Frank James’s mass shooting inflicted on the 10 victims who were shot or the dozens more who suffered other injuries, but this sentence ensures that he will spend the rest of his life in prison for the devastation he caused,” said Attorney General Merrick B. Garland.
James' case has sparked discussions on several fronts - the most important of which is the need for improved mental health support, security of public transportation, and the power of social media as a tool for both expression and warning.
You can check out the PD True episode Hunt for the NY Subway Shooter on Paramount+.