Scariest episodes of Unsolved Mysteries on Netflix, ranked

Unsolved Mysteries is a crime series based on real incidents available on Netflix. It features eerie stories that send chills down viewers' spines. This crime series was initiated in 1987, and with the show's reboot, Netflix offered unsolved cases a new, unsettling angle. This show stands out for its distinctive blending of missing persons cases, cold cases, and paranormal activity.

The show centers on real-life cases that have perplexed detectives for a long time. Every episode looks into a mystery, be it missing people, unexplained deaths, or—most importantly—paranormal activity. Interviews with witnesses, family members, and law enforcement officials are featured in the series, ensuring a thorough examination of each case.

Unsolved Mysteries excels at preserving an unsettling atmosphere that makes viewers uneasy. Know about some of the scariest Unsolved Mysteries episodes on Netflix.

Disclaimer: This list consists of the writer's opinion. Readers' discretion is advised.

---

Some scariest episodes of Unsolved Mysteries on Netflix

Here are some of the scariest episodes you need to watch and explore from Unsolved Mysteries.

• Lady in the Lake
• Dial A For Abduction
• Up in Smokes
• Dreamy Disappearance
• House of Terror
• Poison Pen Murder

1) Lady in the Lake (season 15, episode 11)

Lady in the Lake (Image via Netflix)

This episode centers on the enigmatic vanishment of Grosse Pointe, Michigan resident JoAnn Matouk Romain. Footprints were leading to a nearby lake and JoAnn's car was discovered close to a church. While the police declared her death to be suicide, JoAnn's children believe there was foul play involved. The frightening aspect of the episode is heightened by the potential suspects, who include members of JoAnn's own family.

---

2) Dial A For Abduction (season 4, episode 16)

Dial A For Abduction (Image via Netflix)

Angela Hammond’s abduction while she was on a payphone with her boyfriend is terrifying. Her boyfriend heard her scream and saw a suspicious truck speeding away with her inside. Despite his desperate attempts to follow, Angela was never found. This episode highlights the horrifying reality of abductions and the helplessness felt by those left behind.

---

3) Up in Smoke (season 9, episode 14)

Up in Smoke (Image via Netflix)

This episode explores the phenomenon of spontaneous human combustion, featuring three chilling cases. One case details Kay Fletcher, who survived but experienced smoke erupting from her body. The other two victims were found as piles of ashes, with no explanation for their fiery deaths. The episode’s eerie subject matter and lack of scientific explanation make it particularly unsettling.

---

4) Dreamy Disappearance (season 2, episode 13)

Dreamy Disappearance (Image via Netflix)

Cindy Anderson had terrible dreams in which she was abducted and killed, which adds to the unease surrounding her disappearance. Cindy had dreamed of her own kidnapping a year before she disappeared. An air of dread permeates this episode as viewers wonder what exactly happened to Cindy in light of her mysterious disappearance and the cryptic messages she received beforehand.

---

5) House of Terror (season 15, episode 1)

House of Terror (Image via Netflix)

The episode centers around the gruesome discovery of the bodies of Xavier Dupont de Ligonnes’s family under their house’s porch. The entire family, including their pets, were shot, and Xavier disappeared. The horrifying reality of a family massacre and the mystery of Xavier’s whereabouts make this episode particularly harrowing.

---

6) Poison Pen Murder (season 7, episode 6)

Poison Pen Murder (Image via Netflix)

The Circleville Writer case involves a series of threatening letters sent to residents of Circleville, Ohio, particularly targeting Mary Gillispie. These letters led to the death of Mary’s husband and continued even after a suspect was imprisoned. The mysterious identity of the letter writer and their relentless harassment make this episode deeply disturbing.

---

Unsolved Mysteries on Netflix delves into some of the most bizarre and mysterious real-life circumstances. The series leaves viewers uneasy as they encounter accounts of grisly murders, disappearances, and strange happenings. These mentioned episodes are notable for their frightening themes and lingering questions. After the credits roll, Unsolved Mysteries remains riveting and spine-tingling for true crime and paranormal viewers.