Six Schizophrenic Brothers: What is Anosognosia? Explained

Six Schizophrenic Brothers on HBO Max recounts the terrifying story of the Galvin family, where six brothers out of twelve siblings were suffering from schizophrenia. Known as a severe mental illness, schizophrenia affects reasoning, proper way of thinking, feeling, and behavior.

However, lack of treatment and awareness caused the Galvin brothers great suffering. Anosognosia, a lack of awareness about their mental illness, made treatment and management difficult.

Anosognosia, a term derived from Greek, meaning "lack of knowledge about the disease," is often seen in patients with brain damage or mental disorders. In the case of the Galvin brothers, this condition meant that many of them could not recognize their schizophrenia and it further led to the consequences.

The youngest sister, Lindsay Mary Galvin Rauch, added in an interview with Colorado Springs Gazette, her reaction after watching the series.

Due to their inability to understand their mental state, the brothers refused treatment and medications, increasing their symptoms and complicating the family's situation. A crucial but misunderstood mental health issue is explored in this documentary, through the experiences of the Galvins.

Six Schizophrenic Brothers, released on June 10, 2024, focuses on the lives of the Galvin family, who lived in Colorado Springs. Don and Mimi Galvin raised 10 sons and 2 daughters on Hidden Valley Road in Woodmen Valley, after moving to town in the 1950s. Donald, the oldest, was the first of six boys diagnosed with schizophrenia.

Among twelve children, six brothers have been featured in the story. Through interviews with the youngest Galvin sister, Lindsay, and some archival footage, the documentary shows the family's struggle with mental illness and its impact on their lives.

---

HBO Max's Six Schizophrenic Brothers documentary overlooks Anosognosia

The documentary Six Schizophrenic Brothers on HBO Max has sparked significant controversy, particularly for its portrayal of the Galvin family and its handling of the concept of anosognosia.

While Six Schizophrenic Brothers provides a detailed account of the psychosis, murder, suicide, and incest that plagued the family, it falls short of explaining anosognosia. Anosognosia is a significant factor in understanding the brothers' experiences and their struggles with schizophrenia.

Anosognosia, or "lack of insight," occurs when mental illness sufferers are unaware of their condition. This prevented the Galvin brothers from recognizing their schizophrenia, which made matters worse.

Their treatment noncompliance was due to a lack of an understanding of their illness, not defiance. To have a better understanding of their experiences and the family's challenges, knowing this aspect of their condition is required.

Lindsay mentioned in an interview with Colorado Springs Gazette:

“My poor parents. They’re portrayed as monsters. They were the kindest, most highly educated parents in the world. The series misrepresents schizophrenia grossly.”

Three sons had already passed when Don died in 2003. One of the schizophrenic patients killed his girlfriend and himself. In 2017, Mimi died. Since brain disorder patients get no proper housing, Donald and Matthew live in Pueblo and Springs nursing homes, respectively. Rauch, who lives near Telluride, supports them through The Galvin Family Trust.

According to Lindsay, the documentary's neglect of anosognosia obscures the brothers' struggles. The show ignores anosognosia's role in the brothers' inability to manage their condition, by solely focusing on violence and abuse. The series' omission has offended the surviving family, who believe it misrepresented their reality.

Six Schizophrenic Brothers documentary features interviews with several family members, including Lindsay Mary Galvin Rauch, who expressed disappointment with how her family has been portrayed.

Rauch's brothers, Donald and Matthew, also participated in the documentary. They hoped to highlight the broken mental health system, but the final product, according to Rauch, stigmatized their experiences instead.

While the documentary brings attention to the severe impacts of the disease, it misses a crucial element in its narrative – anosognosia.