Tell Me Lies season 2: What did Lucy do to Lydia? Explained

Tell Me Lies Season 2 made its much-anticipated return on September 4, 2024, once again plunging into the chaotic and intertwined lives of its characters as they go through university dramas and deceptions. The series, which first premiered in 2022, has been directed by Jonathan Levine.

The latest season picks up right where the suspenseful previous episodes left off, re-engaging with the lives of Lucy, Stephen, and their friends. The plot alternates between their college experiences in 2008 and events in 2015, showing how earlier secrets come back to haunt their future. The season deepens the intrigue as past deceptions collide with new revelations, drawing the audience into the dramatic repercussions of their earlier life choices.

Lucy's actions toward Lydia remain shrouded in mystery initially, and it's hinted that Lucy might have had a hand in exposing an incident involving Lydia's brother, Chris, which could have resulted in serious repercussions for him. Lucy supported her friend Pippa in reporting an incident, leading to a serious accusation against Chris and causing a rift between Lucy and Lydia.

The situation likely escalated tensions, leading Lydia to feel betrayed by Lucy, especially if Lucy appeared to side with others over Lydia's family. The exact details of Lucy's actions are gradually revealed as the season progresses, highlighting the complications of their past friendship and the deep fractures that lead Lydia to declare she will never forgive Lucy.

---

Why did Lucy do this to Lydia in Tell Me Lies season 2?

A still from Tell Me Lies season 2 (Image via Hulu)

The rift between Lucy and Lydia in Tell Me Lies season 2 centers on a deeply troubling incident involving Lydia’s brother, Chris, which comes to light during a college party scene, setting the stage for the fallout between the former best friends.

During their sophomore year at Baird College, tension arises when Pippa, one of Lucy's close friends, is found in a compromised state at a party. She is discovered drugged and partially undressed in a room with Chris, who appears visibly shaken and guilty when found by Diana, another friend. Diana and Lucy help Pippa return safely to her dorm, deeply concerned for her well-being and disturbed by the circumstances they found her in.

Lucy, acting in defense of Pippa and seeking justice, takes steps that implicate Chris in what appears to be a s*xual assault. The decision is driven by her commitment to her friend's safety and a strong sense of right and wrong. Lucy supports Pippa in her decision to report the incident and provides her own account of events to the authorities, which adds credibility to the accusations against Chris.

The repercussions of Lucy’s actions are immediate and severe. Lydia, blindsided by the accusations against her brother and distressed by the potential impact on her family, feels betrayed by Lucy. Lydia’s relationship with her brother compels her to defend him, possibly denying the allegations based on her belief in his innocence or her lack of direct knowledge about the events.

A still from Tell Me Lies season 2 (Image via Hulu)

The incident strains the friendship between Lucy and Lydia to breaking point. Lydia confronts Lucy, expressing her anger and disappointment, stating that she can never forgive her for her role in potentially ruining her brother’s life.

The fallout from this event casts a long shadow over their interactions, influencing their dynamics for years to come. As Tell Me Lies season 2 progresses, this crucial moment remains a cornerstone of the plot, showing the enduring impact of college decisions on future relationships and personal growth.

---

Interested viewers can stream Tell Me Lies season 2 on Hulu.