What happened to Alice Hufnagle? Details explored ahead of Philly Homicide on Oxygen 

Alice Hufnagle, a 67-year-old mother and grandmother from East Norriton Township, Pennsylvania, was tragically murdered on November 23, 2002. She was found in her home by her estranged husband, bound with duct tape, s*xually assaulted, and strangled.

Alice worked as a Pharmacy Technician at a Giant Foods supermarket, unaware of her killer. This case is featured on an episode of Philly Homicide on Oxygen, which gives insight into the shocking events and the investigation that followed. The episode is set to air on December 21, 2024.

Police discovered that the perpetrator was Alice's co-worker, Jeffrey Ivan Vample, who was obsessing over her dangerously and ultimately committed the crime. Using investigative techniques, evidence gathered indicted Vample with murder and rape in the first degree and burglary. Vample is currently serving his terms in prison with a permanent life sentence and without probation possibility.

---

How did Alice Hufnagle die?

Alice Hufnagle was a devoted mother of six and grandmother to ten. She lived alone in East Norriton Township after divorcing her husband. Her estranged husband went to Alice's house on November 23, 2002, to fix the toilet in the morning.

Alice's hair was found on the duct tape (Representative Photo by pexels )

He ended up finding an awful view: Alice's partially undressed body lay in the upstairs bedroom, with duct tape traces found in her hair and head. During her autopsy, it was discovered that she had been subjected to brutal r*pe and later died from strangulation along with asphyxiation.

The crime scene had a lot of evidence pointing to the killer, ranging from blood, and hair to body fluids, which can be analyzed in a laboratory. In 2003, Alice Hufnagle's family started offering a $15,000 reward, but their family received no tips at first that could lead to an arrest.

---

Who Killed Alice Hufnagle?

A coworker at Giant Foods identified Jeffrey Ivan Vample, a merchandising employee, as Alice Hufnagle's killer. Vample had a history of obsession with Alice and showed up to work late on the day of the murder with an injured arm. He claimed the injury was from moving furniture, but his story didn’t match the evidence.

Crime scene (Representative Photo by cottonbro studio/pexels )

A search of Vample's home revealed incriminating items: a blood-smeared white mask, a roll of duct tape with hair that looked like Alice's, blood-stained panties, and personal belongings of other women. His calendar highlighted the date of the murder, marked with unsettling notes like "My Love" and "What a Day."

Vample later confessed to breaking into Alice's home to s*xually assault her. He admitted to injuring himself while entering through a glass window and taping Alice's mouth before committing the assault. Fearing she recognized him, he killed her to eliminate any witnesses.

---

What happened to Jeffrey Vample?

Jeffrey Vample was indicted and convicted of first-degree murder, r*pe, and burglary. The prosecution pursued the death penalty, but Vample escaped this with his plea of guilty to all the counts. In court, he expressed remorse to Alice's family by telling them,

"I am truly sorry, and may God bless her soul. I am truly sorry from the bottom of my heart."

Vample was sentenced to life imprisonment with no chance of parole. He is serving his term at SCI Houtzdale in Woodward Township, Clearfield County, Pennsylvania.

---

Alice Hufnagle was brutally murdered in 2002, shocking her community and leaving her family devastated. Her killer, Jeffrey Vample, exploited a workplace connection to commit this crime, leaving behind a trail of evidence that sealed his fate. Oxygen's Philly Homicide revisits this case, offering a detailed examination of the investigation that led to Vample's conviction.