What happened to Cathy McNaughton? Details explored ahead of The Real Murders of Atlanta on ID

The story of Cathy McNaughton will be featured on The Real Murders of Atlanta, a true crime series broadcast on Investigation Discovery (ID). The series shows the darkest crimes in Atlanta and brings to light chilling cases in each episode. The upcoming episode, which will air on August 31, 2024, will focus on the murder of Cathy McNaughton, who was a retired Delta flight attendant.

Cathy McNaughton was found fatally stabbed in her home in Sharpsburg, Georgia, on February 15, 2009, which is the day following Valentine's Day.

She was initially discovered by her husband, Alec McNaughton, who reported her condition to 911 as he found her bleeding on the floor. The investigation quickly shifted its focus towards Alec, spurred by inconsistencies in his account of their "happy" marriage and his activities around the time of Cathy's death.

---

How was Cathy McNaughton murdered?

Noir (Image sourced from Unsplash)

The murder of Cathy McNaughton on February 15, 2009, in Sharpsburg, Georgia, has a tragic story of domestic violence and deception. Cathy was a retired Delta flight attendant and was discovered by her husband, Alec McNaughton, who dialed 911 to report that he had found his wife bleeding profusely on their home floor. His initial display of concern soon became questionable as the investigation deepened.

Alec McNaughton reported a serene Valentine's Day celebration with Cathy, who described an affectionate exchange of gifts and sentiments. However, the portrayal did not align with the emerging evidence. As detectives peeled back the layers of Alec's account, major discrepancies surfaced, particularly concerning his whereabouts on the day of the murder.

Alec claimed to have been away visiting his mother at the time Cathy was likely attacked. However, his cell phone records contradicted his alibi, showing that he was near their home when he claimed to be miles away.

Noir (Image sourced from Unsplash)

The case turned darker as testimonies about Alec's behavior came to light. Sonya Lawrence, who is a close friend of Cathy's and the couple's hairdresser, testified at the trial about Alec's unusual and erratic behavior days before the murder.

She noted a sudden change in his demeanor and appearance which was alarmingly out of character. Additionally, Lawrence revealed that Cathy had expressed concerns over Alec's mental state and their faltering marriage, contradicting Alec's claims of marital bliss.

Further investigation revealed a pattern of Alec's troubling history with women. Testimonies from his previous marriages painted a consistent picture of a man prone to anger and violence. The history and fresh evidence from the crime scene formed a compelling case against him.

Forensic analysis showed that the scene had been staged to mimic a break-in, which was an attempt by Alec to mislead the investigation. No valuables were taken, and the superficial tampering with the home's contents suggested a cover-up.

Noir (Image sourced from Unsplash)

During the trial, the prosecution presented overwhelming evidence of Alec's capability for violence. Previous spouses and acquaintances testified about his aggressive and controlling nature.

The turning point in the trial was the damning testimony regarding Alec's alibi. Cell phone pings and data usage showed that Alec was in the vicinity of their home shortly before Cathy's estimated time of death, undermining his statements about his whereabouts.

Alec McNaughton was convicted in 2010 of the murder and aggravated assault of Cathy McNaughton. He was sentenced to life in prison plus 20 additional years for the assault charge. The conviction was a culmination of a series of investigations that pieced together a profile of a man whose outward charm masked a violent and manipulative nature.

---

Viewers can watch The Real Murders of Atlanta featuring the case of Cathy McNaughton on Investigation Discovery on August 31, 2024, or stream it via the ID app.