When did Robby and Collins date in The Pitt? Timeline explained 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufR_08V38sQ
Still from the series (Image via YouTube/Max)

One of the most compelling elements of The Pitt, a high-octane medical drama about a busy Pittsburgh emergency hospital, is the complicated dynamic between Dr. Michael "Robby" Robinavitch and Dr. Heather Collins. Although the series centers on the high-stakes realm of emergency medicine, the characters' emotional richness, especially Robby and Collins, has had viewers emotionally invested.

Ad

Throughout The Pitt season 1, there are subtle hints that there has been a lot of romantic history between these two characters, which leaves the viewers wondering when and why they broke up.


The Pitt: A relationship that pre-dates season 1

Still from the series (Image via YouTube/Max)
Still from the series (Image via YouTube/Max)

Though the series never presents a definitive timeline for Robby and Collins' affair, several pivotal moments early in the series strongly imply that their relationship transpired years in the past before the events of the show in the present day. Instead of presenting their past in flashbacks, it skilfully adds in ambiguous conversation and emotionally loaded exchanges, maintaining their history subtly vague enough to encourage speculation.

Ad

The most revealing scene is in episode 8, when Collins suffers a traumatic miscarriage. Robby's response to the incident is intensely personal, and his emotional involvement is far greater than that of a friend or co-worker.

This episode is touched upon again later in the series, with a heavy suggestion in episode 11 that the baby could have been Robby's. The subtle but intense implication provides depth to their relationship, affirming that they did have a very intimate connection in the past.

Ad

The Pitt: Emotional pressure

While The Pitt never actually states why Collins and Robby split up, the reasons can easily be discerned based on their natures and life in a high-stress medical environment as depicted in the show. Episode 11, which shows a sensitive exchange between the two physicians in the back of an ambulance, is most revealing. Collins here reveals the emotional burden of her past choices, feeling guilt and regret, particularly regarding the pregnancy and the aftermath.

Ad

It's suggested that the choice to terminate the pregnancy, as well as the subsequent emotional repercussions, was a major factor in their breakup. Collins' emotional distress and Robby's propensity for internalizing sorrow created a dynamic in which communication probably failed.

Robby, having trouble keeping work and his feelings about it separate, had already been laboring under significant emotional loads stemming from the death of his mentor, Dr. Adamson, and subsequently his inability to save Leah. These issues, having never been resolved, caused either one of them not to be able to provide the kind of support that the other required.

Ad

The Pitt: Are Robby and Collins headed for a reunion?

youtube-cover
Ad

Although their love life is supposedly behind them, The Pitt establishes that the narrative between Robby and Collins is far from over. From their first scene together, there's a palpable chemistry that's not missed by their co-stars and the viewers in general. Their increasing candor with each other, particularly as Season 1 unfolds, implies that both characters still have feelings simmering just below the surface.

Season 2 of The Pitt will likely take place a few months after the Season 1 finale. This time jump might be just what the characters require. If Robby has started to recover from the traumas that cloud his mind and Collins has accepted her past decisions, the chance of rekindling their romance becomes highly plausible.

Ad

Robby and Collins' on-again, off-again history is among The Pitt's most emotionally charged subplots. Although the show goes out of its way not to present an exhaustive timeline, it's obvious their love affair took place years before season 1 and was broken up by emotional tension and the high level of stress their job entails.

Yet their residual chemistry still has an impact on their behavior, and the door is open for something to happen down the road. Whether or not they will be together again, their history lends an added emotional depth to one of television's strongest medical dramas.

Ad

Catch the latest episode of The Pitt streaming on Max.

Quick Links

Edited by Sudeshna Banerjee
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications