On November 10, 2024, The Penguin season finale aired on HBO; Max. Selina Kyle, widely recognized as Catwoman, has long been a staple of Gotham’s underworld.
The introduction of Selina, first introduced in The Penguin through a letter to Sofia Falcone, suggests that she may be Sofia's half-sister. It turns out to be an interesting twist about Selina's role and makes one think she might come back in The Batman Part 2.
The Penguin depicts Gotham's criminal underbelly, with Oswald Cobblepot, or The Penguin, seeking control. Sofia Falcone is crucial to Gotham's crime syndicates' power struggle. Sofia receives a letter from Selina Kyle in Arkham Asylum at the series' dramatic finale. This twist casts Selina as a key figure who may shape Sofia's future and Gotham's future.
When Selina Kyle is mentioned briefly in the last episode of The Penguin, fans are left wondering if it's a more permanent reference. With Zoë Kravitz playing Selina in The Batman (2022), her possible return in The Batman Part 2 could give more information about her complicated nature as an antihero and connect her to Gotham's dark history.
The Penguin’s plot and Its Gotham underworld
The Penguin gives readers a deep look into Gotham's dangerous criminal world. The show is mostly about Oswald Cobblepot's fights for power and the violent problems that come with them.
As one of Batman's main enemies, Cobblepot's story is linked to that of other important people, like Sofia Falcone, who's the daughter of the notorious Carmine Falcone.
Throughout the season, Sofia's fight for power further gets highlighted through betrayals and alliances, which give viewers a close look at the dangerous streets of Gotham. Eventually, Sofia's link to Selina Kyle is a surprise that brings her character back to the world of Batman.
An in-depth look into Selina Kyle’s past and Gotham connections
Catwoman began as a thrill-seeking thief and became a complex anti-hero who often blurs the lines between criminal and vigilante. Batman and Selina have a complicated romantic relationship in the comics and movies.
Zoë Kravitz played Selina in the 2022 film The Batman, portraying her as a strong, independent character with her own motives, yet emotionally connected to Gotham's most infamous vigilante.
A secret family tie
At the end of The Penguin, there's a letter to Sofia Falcone that makes one think that she and Selina Kyle have a secret family connection. This new claim adds to the mystery, especially as both have ties to Carmine Falcone, the notorious crime boss in Gotham.
Carmine is often shown as Selina's father in the comics, which makes her Sofia's half-sister. This new information gives both women a chance to work together and creates a storyline that could explore Selina's part in the larger Gotham crime family dynamics in later shows.
An Ally or a Foe?
Depending on her own reasons, Selina Kyle's loyalty changes a lot. This lack of clarity makes it difficult to tell what part she plays in Sofia's life. It's still not clear what she wants with Sofia, but the letter suggests that they might work together.
Selina could work with or against Batman, so she might either help Sofia reach her goals or get in the way of her plans. That makes her a fascinating character who could put Gotham's criminal hierarchy at risk and keep them safe at the same time.
Speculation on Selina Kyle’s return in The Batman Part 2
A return to Gotham?
At the end of The Batman in 2022, Selina left Gotham for Blüdhaven. Even though she left the dangerous streets of Gotham, her link to Sofia suggests that she may still have things to do at home.
This letter and the recent end of The Penguin have made people think that Selina will be back in The Batman Part 2.
Possible inspirations from Dark Victory
Due to The Long Halloween's impact on The Batman, fans think that The Batman Part 2 may use Dark Victory, the sequel to The Long Halloween, which also deals with the mob wars in Gotham.
The storyline of Dark Victory fits well with that of The Penguin and the recent discovery that Selina and Sofia are related. Assuming Matt Reeves decides to adapt parts of Dark Victory, Selina could play a big part, either helping Sofia find her way through the criminal underworld or making her journey even more difficult.
Selina Kyle's reveal as Sofia's half-sister in The Penguin finale expands Gotham's crime story. Selina's unpredictability and complex relationships with allies and foes make her fascinating as Catwoman.
The Batman Part 2 could explore her connection to Sofia. Selina represents Gotham's moral grey area, whether she's Sofia's ally, rival or a mix of both. If Zoë Kravitz reprises her role, Selina Kyle's story may deepen and connect her to Gotham's future.
One can watch The Penguin on Max. The second part of Batman is set to come out on October 2, 2026.