Will there be Based on a True Story season 3? Exploring the possibility based on everything we know so far

Channeling dark humor with rapier-sharp satire on the true crime obsession, Based on a True Story has captured its viewers' imagination with equal portions of jest and suspense. The duo Kaley Cuoco as Ava Bartlett, a realtor-turned-amateur podcaster, and Chris Messina as her hapless husband Nathan, navigates in spots the arbitrariness of podcast culture, suburban life, and serial killer intrigue.

The second season of the series began to premiere in November 2024, with shocking twists, unsettled cliffhangers, and a new layer of complexity in its Westside Ripper saga.

With wit and suspense, Based on a True Story has found its niche among original shows on Peacock. Fans are eagerly waiting for the news of a third season where all this unknown will be answered and another dose of the show's irreverent charm can be enjoyed by viewers.

The platform hasn't said anything official about a renewal as of now, but hints from the showrunner and the positive reception for season 2 suggest there is potential for the continuation of the story.

---

Has Based on a True Story season 3 been renewed?

As of now, Peacock has not announced a renewal for Based on a True Story season 3. Despite this, there’s reason to remain optimistic. The series was quickly renewed for its second season just months after the first premiered in June 2023.

While the writers’ strike in 2023 may have delayed decisions, the strike has since concluded, leaving room for a faster renewal process this time.

Showrunner Annie Weisman has also expressed a hopeful outlook for the show’s future. In a recent interview, Weisman noted that season 2 serves as a self-contained story while leaving the door open for more:

“We certainly hope so," she remarked when asked about the possibility of a third season.

With critical acclaim and steady viewership, the odds of renewal seem favorable, but the final decision will depend on how well season 2 performs on Peacock.

---

What could the plot of Based on a True Story season 3 look like?

The season 2 finale left viewers on edge with multiple unresolved storylines. Most notably, Nathan was arrested after Matt, the Westside Ripper, managed to frame him for his crimes and make a daring escape.

Meanwhile, Ava received a cryptic text from her sister Tory, warning that she was in danger. These twists set the stage for a high-stakes continuation that could explore Nathan’s legal battle and the fallout from Matt’s actions.

Season 3 could also delve deeper into Ava’s moral dilemma as she grapples with her role in this chaotic saga. Tory’s relationship with Matt complicates matters further, potentially placing her at the center of the next chapter’s drama.

The series’ knack for blending dark comedy with suspense ensures that any new season will be filled with unexpected twists, razor-sharp humor, and plenty of chaos.

---

Who would return for Based on a True Story season 3?

The core cast has remained consistent, making their return in a potential third season likely. Kaley Cuoco as Ava and Chris Messina as Nathan are expected to reprise their roles, given that they are central to the story.

Tom Bateman, whose portrayal of the charming yet chilling Matt (aka the Westside Ripper) has been a standout, would almost certainly return to continue his reign of terror.

Liana Liberato’s Tory, Ava’s sister and Matt’s love interest is also poised to play a significant role if the series moves forward. The show may introduce new characters, particularly from the legal realm, as Nathan faces the consequences of being framed for murder.

This fresh dynamic could bring additional layers of intrigue and expand the narrative’s scope.

---

Based on a True Story is currently streaming on Peacock.