#1 Shawn Michaels vs The Undertaker - WrestleMania XXV
This match might just be the best wrestling match we will ever see. Having put on a 5-star classic once before, back in the first ever Hell in A Cell match at Bad Blood 1997, Shawn and Taker managed to have an even better, more incredible match at WrestleMania 25.
Everyone knew Shawn was going to lose, especially since the match had a build up of only about two weeks, but during the match itself, you really believed it was possible Shawn could pull off a win. They kicked out of each other's finishing moves more than once, with perfect exchanges and reversals everywhere, an incredible dive from the ring by Taker and even some of the best frustrated facial expressions you will ever see in a match. This match rightfully won several Match of The Year awards and even spawned a sequel, to be Shawn's final WWE match the following year.
There was no doubt in anyone's mind that after this match, no one else could go out in a 5-star match with Shawn other than The Undertaker. The WrestleMania 26 match between them was excellent, but this match at WrestleMania 25 was just perfect.