#4 The Club
When Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson debuted in WWE last year, there was a lot of hype surrounding them. The two were on an absolute tear in New Japan and on the independent circuit as members of the wildly popular Bullet Club stable, and fans were rightfully excited to see how WWE would capitalize on this popularity.
Sure enough, they didn't. The duo was made to look like fools at the hands of Roman Reigns, who defeated their former leader AJ Styles despite their interference at Payback 2016. This made the formerly dominant team look almost entirely useless, and they haven't done much to remedy their reputation since.
Sure, they won the RAW Tag Team Championships from Sheamus & Cesaro at the beginning of 2017, and yes, they did have a pretty good win-loss record during that time, but the focus never seemed to be on them. It seemed more like other teams, such as Enzo Amore & Big Cass and The New Day, were running the division. After losing their titles to The Hardy Boyz at WrestleMania, the Good Brothers started losing a lot more frequently than they were winning. It's unfortunate, too, because WWE could have easily built upon their success in Japan and established them as a force to be reckoned with.
Instead, they've essentially been booked to look like a couple of...well, nerds.