#4 No Way Jose
No Way Jose's call-up to WWE's main roster was a huge shock - particularly as his NXT run wasn't particularly lighting the world on fire.
Oddly, on this list, he may be the Superstar with the most TV time - but it's usually just for ten seconds of comedy value before he's either demolished in the ring or out of it.
A top AEW star just called one of his colleagues 'spoiled' and 'narcissistic' HERE.
In over a year of being on the main roster, all we know about Jose is he likes dancing. While that may work, smiling on your way to the ring, losing a quick match and disappearing seems like a huge waste of talent.
No Way Jose's WWE run can be summed up in one appearance - he made his Royal Rumble debut and lasted all of two seconds, being eliminated by Samoa Joe.