#8 Triple H vs. The Rock vs. Mick Foley vs. Big Show - WrestleMania 16
There was so much wrong with WrestleMania 16 that it's difficult to narrow it down. In short, Triple H should've faced The Rock in a one-on-one match-up at the event and The Rock should've prevailed. Unfortunately, Foley and Show were added in what became a McMahon-centric feud with Vince, Shane, Linda and Stephanie all having one competitor each.
It was a fairly ridiculous stipulation, and the whole thing was just a shambles. It makes a bit of a mockery of the title and the whole HHH-Rock feud as a whole, especially considering that the latter ended up winning the title just a month later.
It was the personification of the Attitude Era, and to this day it's widely regarded as one of the worst pieces of illogical booking from start to finish. We move seven years into the past for one of the most bizarre matches ever.