#3 Drew Galloway
Since leaving the WWE, Drew Galloway has set the wrestling world on fire. He's made a trip back home help put ICW in the major wrestling spotlight, where he's won their championship twice. Drew has also risen to the top of TNA's roster, where's he's remained as one of the top championship contenders in the company. Drew has been able to explore a more creative side of himself and been seen in a much more competitive light than what he was limited to with the WWE.
Galloway can make an immediate impact back in the WWE, where fans would welcome him back, with excited open arms. There's no need to relegate this guy back to some ridiculous comedic angles, like when he was with 3MB, where he was not able to showcase his true talents. He was expected to stand in the middle of the ring and play an air guitar with Hornswoggle.