#1 Very Mysterious Ice Cream - Cesaro
Ad
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/554da/554da0057e8653e6ed20de4ba070b471aa0be495" alt="hi"
There was simply no other way to end this list.
Ad
Cesaro, The Swiss Superman, wasn't always such a cool character. In fact, things weren't quite so sweet in 2007 when the current RAW Tag Team Champion wrestled under a mask for Chikara as part of Los Ice Creams.
A Very Mysterious Ice Cream was made as part of Los Ice Creams and came out wearing a mask as part of the gimmick. Cesaro wrestled for Chikara for two years before moving onto CZW and ROH.
Ad
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/483c6/483c66b83c0a0fad503b1c24a08b018a8c6184e9" alt="<p>"
If New Day ever get round to bringing out their ice cream, a Superstar (milk)Shake-up may be in order to give them a fourth member to man the van.
Edited by Nikhil Bhaskar