#9 Tye Dillinger
I think a lot of people would agree with me on this choice as well. Dillinger is a guy who has all the potential in the world. In the few times he’s been given the opportunity to try to live up to it, even for just a brief moment, he has made the most of it and proven that he deserves to be more than just a low-card enhancement wrestler. Most WWE superstars also agree with this. Check out Twitter for yourself, and see how many of the current WWE roster members praise Dillinger as one of the most all-around talented guys that the company has to offer.
Tye is a stellar in-ring performer, and as a 16-year veteran, he’s not getting any younger. He just turned 37, so it’s not like time has run out by any means, but if WWE doesn’t utilize the talent that he has, they are just throwing money in the toilet. He can play a cocky heel and he shines as an underdog babyface, with the ability to convey seriousness, humility, and sincerity better than almost anybody in the business. Once WrestleMania is said and done, Tye would be a perfect candidate to start a climb toward the United States Championship and would be a great eventual challenger to either a heel Randy Orton or a heel Bobby Roode. Either feud would be money.