#6. Tommy Dreamer and Beulah McGillicutty

Regular listeners to E&C's Pod of Awesomeness are familiar with their Tommy Dreamer's frequent feature segment, Tales from the Indies, wherein Dreamer recounts the trials and travails he experiences keeping the wrestling dream alive in smaller venues nationwide; one mainstay of these segments is Dreamer's frequent mentions of his suburban-sitcom-dad life with fellow ECW alumni Beulah McGillicutty.
Cody has no chance against John Cena? Details HERE
The strangest thing about these segments is the fact that Dreamer, who took more hard hits than anyone in Philadelphia not named Rocky Balboa, and McGillicutty, who once drew nearly enough blood from Bill Alfonso to kill the former referee, seem like any other middle-aged couple next door.
Yet another couple connected by kayfabe, Dreamer was McGillicutty's storyline high school crush, but Dreamer (the babyface here, because this is ECW, after all) rejected her because she was overweight; now in athletic shape, McGillicutty got her "revenge" on Dreamer by sleeping with Tommy's arch-nemesis, Raven.

A 2006 One Night Stand mixed tag-team match excepted (where Edge pinned her in as suggestive a manner as one can pin an opponent), Beulah's in-ring career ended in the late 1990s, her neck broken in storyline by the Dudley Boyz.
The First Couple of Extreme have twin daughters who had their own IMDB pages in infancy, having played Tony Soprano's baby niece in a sixth season episode of The Sopranos.