#9 Darren Young
Darren Young’s wrestling career can be described as ‘start/stop’. Every time he achieved any momentum whatsoever, it lasted only a few months before the plug was pulled and he disappeared off television. This happened several times since 2013.
He was given something of a sustained push when he came out, he had some popularity when he was teaming with Titus O’Neil, and he returned under the ‘Make Darren Young Great Again’ gimmick.
After a decent initial push in all circumstances, the backstage office gave up or lost interest in him, and he kept disappearing. By this point, it’s likely that WWE considers his regular pushes to have been failures, hence, his lack of regular appearances.
Young is currently sidelined with an injury, but given how little faith there appears to be in him at this point, he should try following in Cody Rhodes’ footsteps and try his hand on the independent scene.