#6 The Boogeyman - 40
There are very few Superstars in history that evoke a squeamish reaction from the fans, quite like The Boogeyman. Known for his elaborate, theatrical entrance, and his appetite for worms (quite literally), The Boogeyman made quite an impression during his brief stint on WWE’s main roster.
Martin Wright competed on the fourth season of Tough Enough in 2004 but was eliminated from the show for lying about his age. Wright entered the competition, by falsely claiming that he was 30 years old when he was in fact 40. Tough Enough’s cut-off age at the time was 35, which forced the company to disqualify Wright from the competition.
However, he made his OVW debut in 2005, and made his main roster debut by the end of the year!