#12 Eva Marie
Eva Marie appeared on every season of Total Divas between 2013 and 2017 before mutually agreeing to leave WWE in August 2017.
The former NXT Superstar has mentioned in various media interviews since her departure that she could see herself returning to the company one day. However, for now, she is focusing on her acting career outside of WWE and Total Divas.
#11 JoJo
An original cast member on the first season of Total Divas, JoJo did not feature at all on the second season of the show before appearing sporadically in every other season.
Speaking on Talk Is Jericho in 2014, Brie Bella explained that JoJo likely left the show after one season due to her age – she was only 19 at the time – while Cameron said the ring announcer had “star quality” but struggled to shine as much when the cameras were on.