#2 Loved: Sycho Sid

Sycho Sid spent three years with WWE over two different spells in the 1990s (May 1991-April 1992 and February 1995-July 1997), and you only have to look at his accolades during that short amount of time to realise that Vince McMahon was a big fan of him.
The 317-pounder held the WWE World Heavyweight Championship on two occasions, while he headlined WrestleMania VIII against Hulk Hogan and WrestleMania 13 against The Undertaker.
Speaking on Prime Time with Sean Mooney in June 2018, Sid revealed that Vince had even agreed to make him one of WWE’s most high-profile Superstars by giving him “Hulk Hogan’s spot”. However, he accepted a guaranteed $750,000 deal from WCW and joined WWE's rivals instead.