#1 Scott Hall
Scott Hall may be the most surprising name on this list. He was a headliner for the company from the moment he walked through the crowd in that denim outfit. Hall was at the forefront of the nWo invasion angle. Scott Hall won the Television Championship, the United States Championship, and the Tag Titles while he was in WCW. Hall was the victor of a 60-man Battle Royal to earn a shot against Sting for the World Title. Hall went on to lose his attempt at the World Title at Souled Out 1998.
Hall ended up being a two-time US Champion, a seven-time WCW Tag Champ, and one reign as the Television Champion. He was at the head of one of the biggest storylines in the history of wrestling. Scott Hall is arguably the biggest star to never win the WCW title based on his position in the company. Hall certainly had the skills to carry the “Big Gold Belt” but it never happened.