#1. WWE fans don't want to see return: Goldberg

Goldberg is arguably the most polarizing part-timer in WWE today. While there's a large section of non-vocal fans who adore and respect the legend, the vocal audience lets WWE know that they aren't big on the two-time Universal Champion.
Somehow, Goldberg always returns, and he mostly does so for World Championship matches. Although this ideally shouldn't count on the list because he has already returned in 2021, he's still a part-time star who many WWE fans don't want to see return.
There are two main arguments fans have against his return. Firstly, many feel that the quality of his in-ring performances and short matches aren't as fun to watch. Secondly, there's a sentiment that Goldberg's appearances mean that a deserving full-time WWE star gets a major spot taken away.
Regardless, there's a reason why WWE keeps bringing him back. He has proven to be a big draw and brings a lot more interest - regardless of how polarizing he can be. Whether fans love him or hate him, they tend to tune into his appearances.