#1 Shocked Undertaker Guy (Elis Mbeh)
If you ask a lifelong wrestling fan about the most shocking moment they've ever experienced over the course of their fandom, there's a high chance that their answer would be the moment when Undertaker's WrestleMania undefeated streak came to an end.
The Deadman's streak was a legendary series of wins at the grandest stage of them all, beginning way back in 1991, when The Undertaker defeated Jimmy Snuka in his Mania debut. After going through some of the greatest wrestlers in the industry over the course of the next two decades, Taker finally fell prey to the beast, the former UFC champion, Brock Lesnar.
The moment Lesnar pinned Taker, the entire arena went into stunned silence. A visibly shocked Paul Heyman screamed joyously, while the camera shifted to the fans in the arena, capturing Mbeh in a state of utter shock. WWE went ahead and featured him on their list of the most famous fans, he got to meet with the Deadman, and of course, was turned into one of the most famous memes of 2014.