#3 Robert Roode
Roode has been a part of some great tag teams in his wrestling career. In Impact, he was a Tag Team Champion alongside the likes of Austin Aries and James Storm. In WWE, in addition to a United States Championship run, he's won tag team gold alongside Chad Gable and Dolph Ziggler.
For this version of the Four Horsemen, I would pair Roode up in a tag team along with the next man on the list. They'ave already tagged together and done so successfully. Roode plays a great heel and already dresses in robes extremely reminiscent of the Nature Boy himself. The Glorious One even teamed up with Flair's daughter, Charlotte, during one season of the Mixed Match Challenge.
Just like Anderson and Blanchard, Roode and Ziggler would be the featured team in the new version of the Four Horsemen. They are both extremely talented veterans and both men look like a million bucks. They might be a little too orange, but that hasn't stopped them from holding together both the tag divisions and mid-card of WWE as heels.
The Glorious One has been off TV for a few months but would be a good fit in a new version of the Four Horsemen. He's over 40 but is still in incredible shape.