#4 Seth Rollins vs. Rey Mysterio: Eye for an Eye
Some things in WWE are so ridiculous that it is impossible to suspend our disbelief. The first leg of Seth Rollins and Rey Mysterio's feud was just that. The Architect sent Mysterio eye first into the edge of the steel steps, which led to the Eye for an Eye Match between the two of them at Extreme Rules.
While well wrestled, the match remains infamous for its ending as the masked legend's 'eye' was out of its socket. The entire basis of this feud was terrible and while it did pick up thanks to Dominik Mysterio's in-ring debut, WWE should not have built it around eye-related offense.
New Champs in WWE! More RIGHT HERE
Rollins ended up tangled with the Mysterio family for six whole months, with a large portion of that being unnecessary filler. The inclusion of Aalyah Mysterio was not that much more inspiring. But well, at least it ended with a bang as both, Rey Mysterio and Murphy picked up big victories over Seth Rollins.
That being said, the vast majority of that rivalry was a real chore to get through. The Eye for an Eye concept was ridiculous right from its birth. WWE could have booked the Rollins vs. Mysterio saga so much better than it did, especially since it took up a large chunk of both Superstars' years.