#1 Karl Anderson
Karl Anderson made his debut in WWE in April 2016 as a part of The Club. He alongside Luke Gallows and created havoc in the tag-team division. It looked like there was a bright future for the two, but WWE failed to provide them with a push, and the duo is now relegated to the background as part of the Balor Club.
Anderson is not exactly a jobber but has been recently booked to look like one. During his time in New Japan, he was arguably the best mic worker in the promotion. His promos as a part of the Bullet Club were as good as anyone else's in the pro-wrestling business.
In WWE though, he is void of the attention he deserves. The creative should not waste any more time in harnessing the true potential of Karl Anderson.