Tyler Breeze
Now may think that this is a slightly odd choice, however Tyler Breeze is much more than just a tag team comedy gimmick.
Prince Pretty was one of the original standout talents from the NXT 2.0 roster along with the likes of Sami Zayn, Adrian Neville (PAC) and Bo Dallas. When the time came Breeze was trusted to have main event caliber matches with the best that NXT had to offer. The company even brought in New Japan Pro Wrestling legend Jushin Thunder Liger for a special one off bout against Breeze.
With Balor returning seemingly as the 'heart and soul' of the previous NXT incarnation there's an opportunity for Breeze to step up and stake his claim, as funnily he was there before Balor and helped NXT move into the 'Takeover' era.
In ring Breeze still has the credentials to deliver a seriously spectacular bout, and the newly rechristened 'Prince' Balor would be the ideal foil for a man who would be looking to showcase just how good he really is.