#4 Eva Marie
Professional wrestler turned actress Eva Marie did not have a very entertaining career in WWE either. She had beef with her female colleagues, as seen in Total Divas, where she was accused of using WWE to boost her own image for her brand and acting career. She wasn't liked by fans either, and was occasionally booed every time she made her presence known in the arena.
She barely knew how to wrestle, and she botched certain moves in her matches and had very weak mic skills. There wasn't anything good about her in WWE, and no one ever looks back and says "I miss Eva Marie". She did not have a very promising run on the main roster, which lead her to move to NXT.
In February 2017, Eva Marie had begun pursuing interests outside of wrestling and began removing WWE references from her social media accounts. In July last year, it was announced that she would not be returning to the seventh season of WWE Total Divas. In August, Eva Marie announced that she and WWE had parted ways. She went on to become an actress, which makes the accusations of her using WWE to boost her image a bit true.