#1 Mordecai
The anti-Undertaker, Mordecai debuted in WWE in 2004, destroying opponents on SmackDown.
Quoting bible-verse and dressed all in white, the Superstar was clearly meant to feud with The Undertaker, who had returned at WrestleMania 20 in March that year.
A former WWE writer just went after JBL for his comments HERE
The pale rider, as he was called by Tazz on Cole, started strong, destroying Scotty 2 Hotty at the appropriately titled Judgment Day pay per view.
Whilst Mordecai promised to make fans pay for their sins, the gimmick was quickly sidelined, after a match with Hardcore Holly at the Great American Bash. The feud with the Deadman never took place and the wrestler Kevin Fertig was later repackaged as the Vampire Kevin Thorne for ECW's return in 2006.