#1 Chelsea Green
Those of you that don't know Chelsea Green, just know that she's a part of NXT right now and she's going to be the next big thing. Impact Wrestling fans will probably know her as Laurel Van Ness, a character she played for the company.
Charlotte Flair to return and wrestle a CURRENT CHAMPION?
If she seems familiar to you guys, it's because she also played the part of Megan Miller, Daniel Bryan's physical therapist. She's no stranger to the dark side either having played Reklusa on the fourth season of Lucha Underground recently.
Green is used to roles where she has to play the part of over the top characters, and I think one of the best ways to introduce her to the world would be as Abby The Witch. Green is already an established name considering that she was also a part of All In, and may not need a complete NXT run.
Whom would you like to see as Abby The Witch, dear reader?