#1. Former WWE NXT North American Champion Bronson Reed - 72.73%
Bronson Reed's NXT win percentage looks like it's going to stay at 72.73% given that he just dropped the North American Title after competing in a match on Main Event, hinting that he's moving on up to RAW or SmackDown.
Still, that makes him the fifth-best Superstar in NXT to have competed in at least five matches in terms of win percentage, with Reed winning eight of the eleven matches he's been involved in.
Obviously, the most recent loss came on this week's NXT as Reed would lose the NXT North American Title to Hit Row leader Isaiah 'Swerve' Scott. Bronson Reed's other losses came in a singles match against Karrion Kross and an 11-man battle royal loss.
Like Kross, Reed is two-for-two on WWE's main roster with a win over Bobby Roode in a dark match and a win over Drew Gulak on WWE Main Event. I wonder which one of Kross and Reed will lose a match first.