#5 - Todd Frazier of the New York Mets
A former teammate of the aforementioned Tommy Kahnle -- since the third baseman is now part of the Mets organization -- Todd Frazier also previously played for the Cincinnati Reds and the Chicago White Sox. He is a two-time MLB All-Star and a Home Run Derby champion, beyond being recognized with a Heart And Hustle Award, which goes to a player that "best embodies the values, spirits, and traditions of baseball."
In a YES Network interview from 2017, Todd Frazier noted that he had attended SummerSlam 1997 in East Rutherford, New Jersey, which had the main event as The Undertaker versus Bret Hart with Shawn Michaels serving as the special guest referee.
However, Frazier's favorite WWE event of all is the Royal Rumble. Frazier's earlier days in the MLB included working with Dale Torborg, who was known in WCW as the KISS Demon and currently works as a strength and conditioning coach within the MLB ranks.
As noted about Frazier in that interview with YES, Frazier is known to have competitions with other people in which they go "back and forth naming wrestlers." However, unlike the aforementioned Josh Reddick, Frazier mostly walks up to his at-bats with songs below fellow New Jersey native Frank Sinatra.