#4 Shelton Benjamin
Despite being one of the most gifted wrestlers of his generation, Shelton Benjamin never got the opportunity to show his skills inside an Elimination Chamber. During his initial run in WWE, 'The Gold Standard' was receiving a major push by the management, thanks to his association with Kurt Angle and Charlie Haas. Shelton won the United States Championship, the Intercontinental Championship, and was a two time Tag Team champion with Haas.
A slick performer between the ropes, Benjamin has always been massively underrated throughout his entire career. His accomplishments and credentials were not enough for him to get a main event level push from the authorities backstage.
Although he never won any World Championship during both his tenures in WWE, his popularity stems from the fact that the audiences love his in-ring skills. His moves and counters have been very well documented and he will be remembered for some of the craziest moments inside the ring during the Ruthless Aggression Era.