#1 Seth Rollins and Murphy planned it all along
Seth Rollins is as cunning and conniving as they come, and Murphy has proved time and time again that he is a loyal disciple.
The Messiah's feud with the Mysterios is borderline obsessive. It all started in May with matches against Rey Mysterio, which would result in a missing eye. Domimik would follow in August at Summerslam and after many intense matches, Rollins would turn his attentions to Aalyah.
Aalyah became the central part of the stroyline ever since she showed sympathy toward Murphy as he lay beaten after yet another attack by his leader, The Monday Night Messiah.
Her actions set the wrestling world alight as it seemed a new storyline was on its way between them. Aalyah has been featured heavily in the weeks following the angle with her, and the two have been protective of one another.
Things between Rollins, Murphy and the Mysterio family escalted when he would expose a DM conversation between Murphy and Aalyah.
This was the final straw for the long suffering follower and Murphy would take revenge on Rollins.
The relationship between Aalyah and Murphy is driving a wedge between Aalyah and her family, which is exactly what the evil and manical Rollins wants. As we have seen in the past, despite the constant abuse, Murphy has been a loyal subject and follower of him.
Rollins and Murphy being on the same page and using Aalyah to destroy the Mysterio family from within, would go down as one of cruelest and most villainous plots in WWE history.