5 Scariest wrestlers without makeup

#1 The Boogeyman

The Boogeyman was a wrestler who worked for WWE in the 2000s

The Boogeyman spent around a year in WWE's developmental territory, before making his way to SmackDown in late 2005. The Boogeyman's entire persona was created to scare the fans and the wrestlers who faced him. His elaborate entrance featured an eerie atmosphere, and he would break an alarm clock on his head by bashing it with full force. He also used to eat worms, a sight that was enough to disgust and scare the bravest of fans.

The Boogeyman without makeup (source: Pro wrestling fandom)

The Boogeyman squashed fellow wrestler Simon Dean in his debut match. He soon feuded with JBL, a former WWE Champion, and defeated him in under two minutes at the 2006 Royal Rumble PPV. On the road to WrestleMania 22, The Boogeyman kicked off a feud with Booker T, and the storyline saw Sharmelle getting absolutely terrified by him. He scored a win over Booker T at WrestleMania. He also had a short stint in ECW, before being released in 2009. The Boogeyman never held a title during his WWE run.