The Demon Kid
Ad

Imagine this: Kane kidnapped Lita and convinced her to have sex with him so Kane could have a demon baby. Kane did this so he could interfere in Lita's love for Matt Hardy. Lita did get pregnant but the storyline ended on a rather sour note when Snitsky knocked Kane into her, causing a miscarriage.
Ad
Giving birth to a hand

During Mark Henry's "Sexual Chocolate" gimmick, mark Henry impregnated then 77-year-old Mae Young. In the 2000's, as part of the storyline, Mae Young gave birth to a rubber hand. I literally have no words about this storyline.
Edited by Gabby Duran