#5 Should Be - Bray Wyatt
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/88872/88872a4eaffc59f50e2332acf0ad9279f22656b5" alt="The Eater of the Worlds needs to return"
The rumor mill was abuzz with the rumor that Bray Wyatt would make his much-awaited return at WWE Crown Jewel to help the Monster among Men, Braun Strowman capture the Universal Championship.
However, Wyatt didn't appear, nor did Strowman win the championship in Riyadh. Instead, Wyatt remains off television and Strowman got decimated by Brock Lesnar.
With Baron Corbin possibly leading the team and even protecting his job, Wyatt could be just the man he is looking for for his team. Bray Wyatt is a former 2-time tag team champion, former WWE Champion and even was one of the survivors of the Men's 5-on-5 match at Survivor Series 2016.
These accolades should be enough to tempt the Lone Wolf to pick the Eater of the Worlds and considering that he has been absent from WWE programming for a while, he could even make his surprise return at Survivor Series where Corbin would introduce him as the team's final member.