#2 Bray Wyatt
After the Mordecai debacle, WWE refrained from scouting the second coming of the Undertaker until they came across a hopeless case in Husky Harris.
The son of the legendary I.R.S was going nowhere as the fattest member of Nexus in 2011 and was rightfully written off television for a character revamp. Thus, The Wyatt Family was born.
Repackaged as Bray Wyatt along with his followers in Luke Harper, Erick Rowan, and later on Braun Strowman, WWE managed to create a worthy-enough candidate to replace Taker.
Then again, WWE Creative did their thing and Wyatt is now just a glorified jobber. From losing to the Undertaker at WrestleMania 31 to his mismanaged WWE title reign, the Eater of Worlds has sadly become the eater of pins.
Similar to his predecessor the Undertaker, Wyatt had a mysterious character with a rich backstory that was backed up with an awe-inspiring entrance. Wyatt, though, still has time and so does the final name on this list.