#2 Bray Wyatt almost turned face in 2016
There was a time when Bray Wyatt was seemingly ready to turn face before the storyline got dumped. In early 2016, Wyatt took on the League of Nations, and while doing so, he started to work together alongside Roman Reigns.
The two had been long-time rivals, but their rivalry was set aside so that they could deal with a bigger threat in WWE. While it was not confirmed that Wyatt was going to turn face, he started acting more like a babyface during the storyline. The first few weeks looked promising and if WWE had followed through on it, it could have been an interesting storyline.
Unfortunately, at the same time, Bray Wyatt was sidelined thanks to a calf injury in real life. He would return months later, and by that time, the storyline had changed. The Wyatt Family then took on The New Day in a feud, where they portrayed heels. The old angle was never mentioned again, and Wyatt never really turned into a proper face at the time.