#4 HHH beats Goldberg
Summerslam 2003 hosted the second version of the WWE's Elimination Chamber match, and this one was star-studded with HHH, Jericho, Shawn Michaels, Randy Orton, Kevin Nash and Goldberg being the lineup, all sure-fire Hall of Famer's. Goldberg had joined WWE in March of 2003 and the likelihood of him tearing through the WWE roster as he did in WCW was high. HHH had other ideas however and after Goldberg had made his way through the rest of the participants in the Chamber Match, HHH laid out Goldberg with a sledgehammer shot to the forehead.
The shock here was not that HHH would win, or he used a sledgehammer to do it, but that Goldberg lost in the WWE after a record-breaking undefeated streak in WCW only a few years earlier.