#4 Boogeyman vs. Booker T & Sharmell – WrestleMania 22
The Boogeyman was a gimmick that should not have worked but somehow did. He was a unique gimmick that grabbed fans’ attention by being disturbing and gross, and that was before he ever had a match.
New Champs in WWE! More RIGHT HERE
He made people uncomfortable in his non-wrestling segments, but he was even worse in the ring. Boogeyman was a 42-year-old rookie and was incredibly limited in terms of what he could do. So when he wrestled against Booker T, you knew it wasn’t going to be anything exceptional.
Boogeyman's offense was limited to poorly-executed strikes and Irish whips, and his finisher was a type of powerslam that didn’t look too impressive. In fact, the only part of the match that anyone really cared about was the worms that Boogeyman brought out.
That got a mild reaction, but not the big pop WWE were likely hoping for. This was a complete waste of time and was a major disservice to Booker T’s abilities as a wrestler.