#1 Kaitlyn vs. Maxine – NXT
Check out which wrestler EC3 finds cute RIGHT HERE
The following phrase is what Michael Cole (who is the voice of Vincent Kennedy McMahon) thought of this segment: "We've sat through a lot of bad stuff on this show, but this may be the single worst segment of this show that I've ever been a part of."
He then proceeded to take a phone call as this match was happening, because the said phone call was clearly 100 times more exciting than this match.
Then again, what did WWE expect when they put two completely inexperienced rookies together in a match?
Maxine looked completely unprepared to wrestle, and Kaitlyn wrestled in a hoodie. They did very basic moves that were either executed wrongly or were sold poorly. The crowd was not into this match whatsoever. The situation wasn’t helped by either Alicia Fox or Vickie Guerrero, both of whom screamed awful advice at their respective rookies in shrill voices.
Oddly, the only entertaining thing about this entire segment was Michael Cole (now there’s a phrase you never thought you’d see, right?). Cole utterly destroyed this match on commentary, taking digs at the show, the wrestlers, Josh Matthews, and everything and everyone around him. His words and actions spoke a thousand words: he did not care one bit about this match, and neither should you.
It was an utter trainwreck that marked the absolute nadir of NXT. Thankfully, Triple H would take over a few years later and turn NXT into something that was actually watchable.