#4 Mr. McMahon
The dirtiest player of all time should never – EVER – return to the ring in a wrestling role. As the Mr. McMahon character, Vince McMahon has a permanent place in the company and history.
McMahon created chaos and cash for his company in becoming a champion himself and wrestling the likes of Steve Austin – creating the greatest feud in wrestling history. Time, however, has passed him by. To his credit, not many 71-year-old men are as jacked as he is and he still looks like he could hurt someone in the ring if given a chance.
Still, the fact that he was injured recently while working out gives you an idea that the notion of locking it up again with an opponent is as bad an idea as any in recent memory.