#2 Bayley
Even when the WWE tries to turn her heel, Bayley still has a rabid fan base. Examining why isn't so clear-cut.
She's a talented athlete, but there are many talented women in the WWE right now. Bayley has everyone from young children to middle-aged men cosplaying her ring attire and cheering wildly at her entrances.
Why she has a cult following: Like Colt Cabana, Bayley seems approachable. She doesn't have the 'goddess' quality or the etherealness of other women like Alexa Bliss. Likewise, her warm personality shines through no matter the odds or situation she finds herself in. Fans love wrestlers who never quit fighting, and Bayley manages to straddle the role of good girl and combatant with equal aplomb.