#1 Rey Mysterio Vs. Eddie Guerrero Vs. CM Punk

Possibly the biggest dream match on this list, a battle between three of the most athletic stars in wrestling history couldn't be contained by WWE.
Instead, this match took place at IWA Mid South Wrestling, this match is even more shocking for featuring a maskless Rey Mysterio.
Did you know a top WWE Superstar just wrestled outside the company? More details HERE
Taking place in March 2002 (in a brief instance where Guerrero had been fired from the WWF), the three future World Champions met for Punk's Mid South Heavyweight Championship, with Guerrero picking up the win over his good friend and future Second City Savior.
Losing the title the next night, back to Punk, all three men proved themselves to the small crowd in attendance, and it's no wonder why these three are still regarded as three of the very best by any wrestling fan.