#2 Bobby Lashley
At the 2006 ECW pay per view event December to Dismember, Bobby Lashley defeated Big Show, Test, Rob Van Dam, Hardcore Holly and CM Punk to capture the Extreme Championship Wrestling heavyweight title in the Elimination Chamber. This victory has the unfortunate distinction of occurring in what has long been considered one of the worst pay per views in WWE's reincarnation of the brand. Not only did he defeat the late Andrew ‘Test' Martin and then champion the Big Show, this was also one of CM Punk's earliest pay per view appearances for the company.
Today, Lashley has made a name for himself by diversifying his activities, becoming quite the businessman even as he stayed active in MMA with Bellator and wrestling with Impact Wrestling. It was recently reported that Lashley had signed with WWE, or would do so imminently, as his contract with Impact Wrestling had come to an end. While he hasn't appeared in WWE yet, when he finally does it will certainly be a moment that will turn heads.