#1. WWE Superstar Eva Marie
Three weeks before Eva Marie's WWE tryout, her now-husband, Jonathan Coyle, followed her on Instagram because he thought she was pretty attractive. According to Eva Marie, Coyle liked a few of her photos, so she was curious to know who that guy was.
The WWE Superstar thought Coyle was cute after she checked out his Instagram profile and saw his CrossFit photoshoots.
New Champs in WWE! More RIGHT HERE
"I think she commented on my post first. There is a CrossFit photo and I think she was like, 'oh, I wanna try CrossFit'. Of course, you wanna try CrossFit. How many girls that hit me up on Instagram being 'they want to try CrossFit?' So, I was like 'Alright, cool, she is super hot. I hit her back. I didn't give her my number, and this is before the days of DM or anything, so I'm not trying to give some girl my number who I didn't know. I was like 'hey, you can email me.' So I give her my work email," Coyle said in a video on his wife's YouTube channel.
About a day later, Coyle received an e-mail from Eva Marie with her phone number. As Coyle was about to text her, his phone crashed. After disappearing for some time, the CrossFit expert got in touch with Eva Marie to tell her what had happened, but she did not buy his excuse and thought he was rude.
A few days later, Coyle invited the WWE Superstar to train with him at his CrossFit gym in Los Angeles on a Saturday. Two days earlier, Eva Marie texted him saying she had already signed up for a CrossFit gym in Orange County and thanked him for his help. Coyle was surprised because he thought she did not really want to do CrossFit but hang out. It turned out he was wrong.
Following that, Coyle was determined to meet the 36-year-old. Despite his busy work schedule, he left the office to meet Eva Marie as she went to train on a Monday. While Coyle was warming up doing pull-ups, the WWE Superstar walked in, and he almost fell on his face.
"As I'm doing that, she walks in and it was like the movies where it's like 'It's the end of the world as we know it'. My life just went 'shooot' I remember getting so distracted that I almost busted my chin on a muscle up and I got down and I was like (speechless with an open mouth). She was like 'hey, what's up. I'm Natalie' and I'm like (speechless with an open mouth)."
From Eva Marie's side, she thought something was wrong with Coyle. The big macho CrossFit guy could not speak. He described their first encounter as awkward and weird. After their workout, Coyle walked Eva Marie to her car, said goodbye to her, and left.
Just as Eva Marie drove away, he called her and convinced her to turn back and go with him for a juice. Although the WWE Superstar thought he should have asked her while he walked her to the car, she accepted his invitation.
Eva Marie and Coyle tied the knot in 2014. Their wedding aired on WWE's reality show, Total Divas. The All Red Everything recently returned to WWE after nearly four years of absence.