#2 Goldberg
As one of the biggest stars in WCW history, Goldberg was always destined for great things in the WWE wasn't he? Wrong again. After accumulating an unprecedented 173-match winning streak in WCW, it took less than a few months for Goldberg to lose after debuting in the WWE.
And of course, it had to be to the buzz-smuggler, Triple H himself. Goldberg's air of invincibility completely vanished after The Game pinned him. It wasn't even the fact that he lost, it was the manner in which it was booked.
A small sledgehammer shot was comically enough to keep Bill down for the three count, and after that, the fans never looked at him in the same way again. Now he's back in the WWE being booked as the biggest superstar ever, but we're not buying it.
And judging by the recent RAW attendances, neither are the fans.